Mr. Hankey's Toys Review

If you're honestly frustrated by the sameness of mainstream sex toy retailers - the same 10 shapes, the same three sizes - Mr. Hankey's Toys solves that problem completely. This is a small-batch, made-in-USA operation out of Denver, Colorado, specializing in fantasy and extreme silicone dildos that you genuinely cannot find elsewhere. We're talking tentacle designs, dragon anatomicals, horse-scale replicas, and hyper-realistic human casts that go up to sizes no commercial retailer will carry. We tested the site in March 2026 and the product range is legitimately staggering. They carry over 400 unique molds across multiple firmness options - ultra-soft, medium, and firm - all cast in platinum-cure silicone, which is body-safe, non-porous, and autoclave-sterilizable. Unlike cheaper silicone blends used by mass retailers, platinum-cure doesn't off-gas or degrade. That distinction matters for anything going inside a human body, and Mr. Hankey's makes it clearly on every product page. Real talk: pricing is high by necessity. Small sizes start around $35-$50, but the popular large fantasy models run $80-$200, and the truly extreme sizes push past $400. That's not a budget buy - it's craft pricing for handmade American goods. Billing shows as a neutral descriptor, and shipping arrives in plain unmarked packaging. Their domestic US shipping is reliable; international delivery adds cost and time but is available. Honestly, customer service is the weak point. Response times can stretch 3-5 business days, and order status updates are minimal during production queues that sometimes run 4-6 weeks. For a specialty item you've spent real money on, that communication gap is genuinely frustrating. Our take: best for kink-positive buyers who want extreme or fantasy toys unavailable anywhere else. Skip this if you need quick delivery or prefer products you can return easily - the custom nature of most items makes returns complicated. As of 2026, the site runs HTTPS with a clear privacy policy and no subscription traps.