r/RateMyCock

r/RateMyCock has 659,235 members as of April 2026 and runs on one of Reddit's most interactive feedback loops: men post photos of their penis and commenters actually rate and respond. This isn't passive scrolling - the whole community is built around the exchange. Ratings typically include both size observations and aesthetic commentary, and regulars develop a vocabulary for it. Here's where it gets interesting: the feedback culture is surprisingly honest rather than performatively complimentary, which means you'll see genuine commentary including criticism, not just validation. That directness keeps the community from devolving into pure ego-stroking. Posts are image-only by convention. Who fits here: men curious about how they compare, people who enjoy giving feedback, and those who follow specific posters over time. Our take is that the honesty norm is the community's actual differentiator - most body-rating spaces trend toward hollow flattery, and this one mostly doesn't. Expect thick skin to be useful if you're posting.